Nurses Being More Sensitive to Patient Modesty
Patient modesty needs to be a high priority during all medical procedures. Nurses are often so busy focusing on the actual procedure protecting a patient’s dignity and modesty gets sidelined, especially in the ER and other busy departments. It is important to keep in mind that many patients are more comfortable with same sex medical professionals for intimate procedures.
Oftentimes, patients are more anxious about their modesty for medical/surgical procedures than the actual procedure itself; therefore, many patients have avoided procedures. Most patients welcome medical professionals of either sex for procedures and exams which do not expose their private parts. Intimate procedures are another story. Many patients prefer same sex intimate medical care such as assisted bathing, insertion of urinary catheters, and assisted dressing. For example, many women prefer a female nurse for intimate care. Many men are more comfortable with male nurses for intimate care.
Modern medicine is gender neutral which means providers, nurses and assistants are equally able to offer their services to all patients no matter the sex of the patient involved.
While it may be true that the mechanics of medical care can be provided by either sex to patients of either sex, there are two important issues hospital administration, nursing homes, and medical professionals should consider if “patient centered care” is truly a priority.
1) Many patients have sex preferences
particularly for intimate care.
2) The potential for abuse during intimate care is great particularly when
patients are compromised by medication, anesthesia, or by their physical
condition.
Many patients and family members are totally unaware that gender-neutral intimate care has become the norm at many facilities. They find this out, oftentimes too late, when they or a loved one is hospitalized or admitted to a nursing home. Some examples include: male nurses in Labor & Delivery departments and male nurses / nursing assistants doing intimate care on women such as bathing, changing gowns, inserting urinary catheters, and vaginal prep for surgeries. There is no valid or specific medical reason for gender-neutral care.
It is difficult for a patient or his/her family
to object to this gender-neutral care especially if the patient is in critical
condition. Here’s an example: one husband in New York did not feel
he could speak up at first when some male nurses and techs helped to dress
and bathe his wife who had Endocarditis, a life threatening heart valve
infection that almost killed her. A male nurse washed his wife’s genitals
because she had a horrible yeast infection due to antibiotics she was receiving.
The husband was completely focused on his wife’s survival. Her surgeon
had said it would be a week before they would know if she would pull through.
It’s sad that patients on the verge of possible death are randomly
and routinely subjected to gender-neutral intimate care abuse and as well
as modesty violations. Many women and their husbands assume that a female
patient will always have a female nurse or nursing assistant help with dressing
or bathing. This was the case decades ago but, things have drastically changed
with today’s “modern medicine” becoming increasingly gender
neutral.
Over the past decade there has been a big increase in male medical professionals
- especially nurses and nursing assistants - sexually assaulting women because
they perform intimate care on female patients. Check out www.sexualmisconductbydoctors.com
to see a list of male medical professionals who have sexually abused women
according to news sources.
Ironically, many women’s prisons in a number of states have
policies that prohibit male security guards from stripping female inmates—even
if they are suspected of hiding drugs—or watch them showering.
Hospitals and nursing homes need to address these concerns as well and enact
similar policies by prohibiting male nurses and nursing assistants from
doing intimate procedures on female patients to protect their dignity and
safety.
Departments such as cardiac units, ICU, general surgery, orthopedic surgery,
and psychiatry at in hospitals and nursing homes that serve both female
and male patients should hire nurses of each sex. Accommodating the wishes
of patients with same sex medical care should be a hospital’s priority—and
same sex medical care should be the default where the wishes of the patient
are unknown. For intimate procedures, many nursing departments and even
nursing homes assign nurses to patients without considering the sex of the
patient and without the patient’s or family’s consent.
There is another problem with the gender-neutral
approach in medical facilities that has caused a problem with male patients
who are more comfortable and less embarrassed with male personnel for intimate
care. When a facility assigns a male aide / nurse to some female patients
for intimate care, it limits their availability for helping male patients.
In the 1970s and before the ‘gender-neutral’ era, men had intimate
procedures such as urinary catheterizations done by male doctors or orderlies
in hospital. The gender neutrality of the medical industry changed this
and it is pretty common for female nurses and CNAs to do intimate procedures
on male patients today.
Numerous male patients have been violated by female nurses who ignored their
wishes for modesty. Cases attest to female nurses who have made derogatory
comments about the genitals of male patients especially those under anesthesia.
Male patients should always have the option of an all-male medical team for intimate procedures. Medical facilities should give all male patients forms asking about their gender preferences for intimate medical care.
Interestingly, a number of male nurses refuse
to work in Labor & Delivery department even if it is allowed or are
uncomfortable with doing intimate procedures on female patients, but they
are pressured by their female nursing supervisors who do not seem to be
sensitive to patient modesty.
Some facilities do not have enough male nurses and this poses a problem
for male patients who care about their modesty. Also, male nurses are usually
best suited to lift patients.
*All nurses are encouraged to watch the videos,
Problems
with Medicine Being Gender Neutral and Surgery
and Your Modesty.
Here are some examples of nurses being sensitive to patients’
wishes:
1) A female head nurse helped to honor a man’s wishes for
an all-male team for colonoscopy and colonoscopy shorts by scheduling a
male technician and ordering colonoscopy shorts before his procedure.
2) A female nurse went to find a male nurse to do a urinary
catheter on a man who was more comfortable with a male nurse.
We encourage all nurses to work on being more sensitive to patients. Below
are some tips to use as a guide.
Tips For Nurses
1) Never try to convince a patient
to accept opposite sex medical professionals for intimate procedures. Don’t
use arguments such as “they are professionals”, “they’ve
seen it all”, and “they are very skilled and have done this
procedure many times”.
2) If any colleagues make derogatory comments about patient’s
private parts, report them to the administration. Do not tolerate this behavior.
3) Put a ‘Do Not Disturb’ sign on the exam
door so other medical personnel do not randomly enter during intimate exams.
4) Never walk in a room that is closed because the doctor
may be doing an intimate procedure. Be sure you ask the doctor what he/she
is doing before entering in a room.
5) Let the patient have the choice of who she/he wants
to be present for her/his intimate exams. Ask the patient. Some patients,
especially male patients, do not want any chaperones (ex: female nurse)
to be present. If you have to be present for an intimate exam with a doctor,
you should consider standing at the patient’s head so you can avoid
seeing the patient’s private parts.
5) Ask for permission before you touch certain areas of
any patient’s body. Explain in precise details what you will be doing,
especially if the procedure involves private parts. Always respect a patient’s
wishes if he/she says “No” to something.
6) Let the patient wear their
street clothes as much as possible. Many procedures and tests, including
blood tests, blood pressure tests, stethoscope heart exam, eye, ear, nose,
and throat examinations, as well as throat cultures can be done fully clothed.
Check out the articles about patients wearing their own clothes: Hidden
Beneath the Hospital Gown and Keep
Your Pants, and Your Dignity, at the Hospital.
7) Don’t try to dress or undress a patient especially when they want to do it themselves. Be patient with them no matter how long it may take them.
8) Always strive to give patients maximum dignity and respect. Do not unnecessarily expose them. For many surgical procedures that do not involve the genitals, hips, and groin, patients can wear 100% cotton underwear or disposable underwear/shorts as long as they do not contain metals. Check out Unnecessary Underwear Removal for Surgeries. Utilize special garments such as Covr Medical Garments for procedures that require access to the groin, hip, and part of the back (ex: kidney procedure) and the Modesty Bra for women. If a rectal exam or colonoscopy is required, give the patient the option of wearing boxer shorts backwards or specialized colonoscopy shorts that only expose their buttocks. If a patient requires assistance with bathing, look at getting the honor guard garment from Dignity Resource Council.
9) Never push a patient to accept
nursing or medical students against their wishes.
10) If you cannot accommodate a patient’s wishes
for a same sex team, suggest other facilities or schedule that procedure
when a same sex medical team can be accommodated.
11) Educate your nursing staff to be sensitive to patient
modesty and privacy. For example, a man may not want to discuss his health
issue with a female nurse.
12) During general anesthesia patients
continue to expect dignified care. For patients who require surgery that
involves exposure of their private parts commit to helping them get a same-sex
surgical team if that is their preference. Be open to using local or regional
anesthesia if that is the preference of the patient. This allows the patient
to remain awake and alert during a procedure and gives many patients peace
of mind. Also, patients should have the option of having a personal advocate
such as their spouse present for surgeries and procedures. Check out this
article, Why
You Should Have a Personal Advocate?
13) Treat compromised patients and those who suffer with
dementia and Alzheimer’s with dignity and respect for their privacy.
Always assume that a patient wants to be treated by a medical team of the
same sex if the patient is unable to communicate her/his preference. One
female car accident patient was traumatized when she witnessed a male nurse
removing her tampon while she was semi-conscious.
14) Never routinely perform intimate procedures such as
urinary catheterizations on patients because it is more convenient. For
example, a urinary catheter should never be used for incontinence. Adult
diapers or Depends should be used instead. Check out Unnecessary
Urinary Catheterizations and Lack of Informed Consent.
15) Encourage your facility to make a policy prohibiting
male nurses and assistants from doing intimate procedures on female patients
to prevent potential sexual abuse. Utilize the male nurses for intimate
procedures on male patients as much as possible and use them for non-intimate
procedures on female patients.
